The 13 Best Tasting Cat Foods for Picky Cats

By Nadine Oraby | 2020 Update

It can be nerve-wracking to be a picky eater cat’s parent. As much as cats love their food, they can be pretty particular about their nutrition and flavors – and that’s what their charm is all about.

Your pampered little paw-tner deserves the best nutrition, even if he is a picky eater. And it can be tricky to find a suitable diet that offers complete nutrition and irresistible flavors.

To save you from continuous refusals and your cat from serious health problems, I have compiled a list of best-tasting cat foods for picky eaters below. Learn everything you want about encouraging your picky eater to enjoy their meal…

The Best Tasting Cat Foods for Picky Cats

Top ProductsWhat We Like About This Food…
1. Taste of the Wild Canyon River Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
(Editor’s Choice)
Grain-free recipe, includes smoked salmon for protein and flavors, natural antioxidant support
2. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Cat FoodProtein-rich recipe, grain-free, includes real chicken for delicious flavors
3. Fancy Feast Gourmet Savory Chicken & Turkey Dry Cat Food100% nutritionally complete and balanced meal, delicious finish with a crunchy texture, enchantingly shaped morsels made with chicken and turkey
4. Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Poultry & Beef Feast Variety Pack Canned FoodChunks in gravy texture, 100% complete and balanced nutrition, mouthwatering gravy
5. Natural Balance L.I.D Limited Ingredient Diets Green Pea & Chicken Formula Grain-Free Dry Cat FoodExcellent for sensitive digestion, Limited-Ingredient Diet, delicious grain-free chicken formula

Why your kitty fur baby may have stopped eating? – Here are 8 common reasons:


1. Taste of the Wild Canyon River Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

Top 5 Ingredients: 1. Trout, 2. Ocean Fish Meal, 3. Sweet Potatoes, 4. Potatoes, 5. Pea Protein

This recipe by the Taste of the Wild is crafted with balanced nutrition and delicious flavors that your picky little eater cannot refuse. Prepared with the most nourishing ingredients, the grain-free recipe offers highly-digestible energy for your active cats. This recipe includes the delicious flavors of smoked salmon, trout, sweet potatoes, and peas, and a blend of antioxidants extracted from real fruits and vegetables. Ensure the best essential nutrients with this flavorful recipe that works perfectly for picky eaters.


2. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

Top 5 Ingredients: 1. Deboned Chicken, 2. Chicken Meal, 3. Pea Protein, 4. Peas, 5. Menhaden Fish Meal

You can’t go wrong with this special recipe even with the pickiest eater. Not only the food’s delicious flavors are irresistible for cats, but it also contains nutrients that your felines can thrive on. Make mealtime a nutritious and delightful occasion with this protein-rich, grain-free recipe that is loaded with the flavors of chicken and fish. Chicken serves as the primary source of protein in this recipe to help your feline maintain lean and healthy muscles. The highlight of this recipe is the LifeSource Bits that do not only add flavor to it but also packs it up with antioxidants, minerals, and vitamins for the immune system.  Inspired by the diet of the Lynx, this food option offers a healthy oxidative balance for your cats.


3. Fancy Feast Gourmet Savory Chicken & Turkey Dry Cat Food

Top 5 Ingredients: 1. Ground Rice, 2. Poultry By-Product Meal, 3. Corn Gluten Meal, 4. Beef Tallow, 5. Whole Grain Corn

This Fancy Feast Gourmet recipe has everything that will give your cat a delicious reason to purr. The savory recipe includes a delectable combination of chicken and turkey and serves as a 100% complete and balanced meal for your purr-fect buddy. The crunchy kibble is packed with nutrition to fuel your cat’s active lifestyle. The enchantingly shaped, mouthwatering morsels are meaty and flavorful that your cat will love. Serve your little kitty a meal that’s not only delicious but highly nutritious too.


4. Fancy Feast Gravy Lovers Poultry & Beef Feast Variety Pack Canned Food

Top 5 Ingredients
Turkey Flavored Gravy: 1. Poultry Broth, 2. Turkey, 3. Liver, 4. Chicken, 5. Meat By-Products
Chicken Flavored Gravy: 1. Poultry Broth, 2. Chicken, 3. Liver, 4. Wheat Gluten, 5. Meat By-Products
Beef Flavored Gravy: 1. Meat Broth, 2. Beef, 3. Liver, 4. Wheat Gluten, 5. Meat By-Products

Make mealtime as scrumptious as paw-ssible with this Fancy Feast Gravy food that’s made from a delicious blend of poultry and beef feast variety packs. The canned cat food includes the best combos of cats’ favorite flavors, including beef, turkey, and chicken. What makes it all the more unique and irresistible for cats is its thick gourmet gravy. The tender and delicate bites are slow-cooked to perfection and feature complete and balanced nutrition for your picky eater. Packed with essential minerals and vitamins, this food option for picky eaters is highly recommended.


5. Natural Balance L.I.D Limited Ingredient Diets Green Pea & Chicken Formula Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

Top 5 Ingredients: 1. Green Peas, 2. Chicken Meal, 3. Chicken, 4. Chicken Fat, 5. Pea Protein

Provide your furry friend with the flavors and nutrition she craves. I recommend this Limited-Ingredient Diet for sensitive cats, which are naturally picky eaters. Rich in essential nutrients, the recipe contains only a handful of ingredients, including a single animal protein source. The tasty and crunchy kibble is loaded with minerals, vitamins, taurine, and essential omega fatty acids to support your cat’s wellbeing from nose to their tail – not to mention, their lustrous coat too. The irresistible flavors of this blend will have your cat running to her food bowl every single time.  


6. Friskies Extra Gravy Pate Variety Pack Canned Cat Food – Case of 24

Top 5 Ingredients
Chicken in Savory Gravy: 1. Meat By-Products, 2. Poultry By-Products, 3. Chicken, 4. Fish, 5. Water Sufficient for Processing
Turkey in Savory Gravy: 1. Meat By-Products, 2. Poultry By-Products, 3. Chicken, 4. Turkey, 5. Water for Processing
Salmon in Savory Gravy: 1. Meat By-Products, 2. Poultry By-Products, 3. Chicken, 4. Salmon, 5. Water for Processing
Tuna in Savory Gravy: 1. Meat By-Products, 2. Poultry By-Products, 3. Chicken, 4. Tuna, 5. Water for Processing

Variety is the spice of life, and it’s no different when it comes to cat food. Send your cat on a flavor adventure with this variety feast that offers four mouthwatering recipes featuring poultry, fish, and meat. Prepared in extra gravy, the pate version adds moisture, flavor, and extra yum to every single bite. The tender texture of the food is another plus that makes these recipes more desirable. Each variety is packed with a blend of high-quality ingredients and complete nutrition to support your paw-tner’s overall health and wellness. The variety pack features flavors, including chicken, turkey, salmon, and tuna.


7. Wellness CORE Signature Selects Flaked Skipjack Tuna & Wild Salmon Entrée in Broth Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

Top 5 Ingredients: 1. Tuna, 2. Tuna Broth, 3. Mackerel, 4. Salmon, 5. Water for Processing

This recipe does absolute justice with the brand name. This signature Wellness Core recipe is made with the delicious flavors of wild salmon and flaked skipjack tuna prepared in broth. The grain-free recipe is a delectable and holistic approach to your cat’s diet. The gourmet recipe is packed with taste and naturally delivers the variety and nutrition that your cat craves. This hand-made recipe includes delicate flakes of real tuna and lots of essential fatty acids to keep your cat’s coat and skin in peak condition. Loaded with flavors that your cat cannot resist, this food option is free from by-products, corn, wheat, and soy.


8. Purina Muse Natural Ocean Whitefish & Mackerel Recipe Grain-Free Pate Canned Cat Food

Top 5 Ingredients: 1. Ocean Whitefish, 2. Chicken, 3. Liver, 4. Fish Broth, 5. Mackerel

This recipe by Purina includes carefully sources ingredients such as chicken, ocean whitefish, liver, and mackerel to deliver a flavorful meal your picky eater cannot refuse. Prepared in fish broth, this perfect recipe with prominent seafood and poultry flavors also contains high-quality vegetables to add essential hydration to the bowl. This complete recipe has everything your furry paw-tner needs to feel and look his best. Serve your little kitty a bowl filled with the goodness of unique flavors, antioxidants, taurine, minerals, and vitamins.


9. PetGuard Fish, Chicken & Liver Dinner Canned Cat Food

Top 5 Ingredients: 1. Chicken Broth, 2. Mackerel, 3. Chicken, 4. Chicken Liver, 5. Ocean Fish

The PetGuard canned cat food is a protein-packed recipe that’s enhanced with minerals and vitamins for the overall wellbeing of your cat. The highlight of the recipe is its delicious blend of flavors that make it a delectable option your kitty cannot say no to. Your cat will love this flavorful meal that’s loaded the real flavors of liver and chicken. Other healthy ingredients include kelp and rice. All these ingredients add flavor to the meal and support your cat’s healthy heart, skin and coat, liver function, and aids in nourishing their whole body with the goodness they deserve.  


10. Instinct Original Grain-Free Pate Real Rabbit Recipe Wet Canned Cat Food

Top 5 Ingredients: 1. Rabbit, 2. Pork, 3. Pork Liver, 4. Pork Broth, 5. Ground Flaxseeds

Instinct Original never fails to surprise me when it comes to featuring the best and most flavorful ingredients for pet food. This recipe contains real rabbit, pork, and pork liver, prepared in pork broth for flavors that even the pickiest eater would fall in love with. The protein-rich recipe is free from grains and is inspired by the Instinct’s belief in raw that makes this blend unique. Unlock your feline’s potential to thrive on food that offers complete nutrition with real meat, fruits, and vegetables. The pate texture is not only delicious but packed with natural omega fatty acids.


11. Hill’s Science Diet Kitten Healthy Cuisine Roasted Chicken & Rice Medley Canned Food – Case of 24

Top 5 Ingredients: 1. Chicken Broth, 2. Chicken, 3. Pork Liver, 4. Carrots, 5. Wheat Gluten

If you’re looking for a scrumptious meal for your young kitten who’s not impressed so easily, this recipe is your best bet. Carefully designed with expertise, Hill’s Science Diet is a healthy formula that your kitten needs during his early development and growth stage. Packed with the flavors of real roasted chicken and rice medley, the recipe does not include any harmful preservatives or artificial flavors. This one is a wholesome recipe that offers the perfect balance of nutrition and taste to your beloved little kitten.


12. Taste of the Wild Rocky Mountain Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

Top 5 Ingredients: 1. Chicken Meal, 2. Peas, 3. Sweet Potatoes, 4. Chicken Fat, 5. Pea Protein

This natural recipe by the Taste of the Wild is a balanced diet formulated with high-quality and delicious ingredients. This is one of the best-tasting cat foods that your kitty cannot refuse.  Packed with the flavors of smoked salmon and roasted venison, this grain-free option includes other delectable ingredients to add to the overall flavors of the meal. The formula is rich in natural antioxidants to support digestion and overall wellbeing. Serve your kitty a delicious meal that will keep bringing them back for more.


13. Wellness CORE Simply Shreds Natural Grain-Free Wet Cat Food Topper Variety Pack of 4

Top 5 Ingredients:

Boneless Chicken Recipe: 1. Chicken, 2. Chicken Broth, 3. Water for Processing
Chicken and Mackerel Recipe: 1. Chicken, 2. Chicken Broth, 3. Mackerel, 4. Water for Processing
Tuna and Shrimp Recipe: 1. Tuna, 2. Fish Broth, 3. Water for Processing, 4. Shrimp
Wild Salmon and Tuna Recipe: 1. Salmon, 2. Fish Broth, 3. Water for Processing, 4. Tuna

Fill your cat’s bowl with maximum nutrition and deliciousness with this variety pack loaded with flavors by Wellness CORE. The texture has tender shreds of chicken, tuna, salmon, and mackerel are prepared in broth for added flavors. This works as a perfect wet cat food topper to make every food delicious for a picky eater. The chicken and seafood diet with limited ingredients is natural and grain-free and is rich in taste to boost the flavors of any meal you top it up with. This is a must-have if you have a picky eater at home.


Buyer’s Guide

Dealing with a cat that’s too picky about food? This little guide here can help you understand the reasons and figure out possible solutions to feeding the pickiest eater.

Why Is My Cat So Picky?

Cats are creature of habit. They prefer following a routine and are particular about what they like or don’t like. There are many reasons why your cat could be giving you a hard time eating her food. Here are the most common reasons:

Neophobia

Neophobia is a term used for the irrational fear one feels about new things. This is as common in cats as it is in humans. If you have been feeding her new varieties of cat food, they may consider the unfamiliar taste as dangerous and confusing, especially if they’re not used to eating different kinds of food.

On the other hand, some cats enjoy trying out new varieties to break the monotony. If your cat is refusing new food and if you really need to introduce better food to your cat, take a gradual approach. Try mixing the new food with old one first and slowly replace the whole thing to see how your cat reacts. You will understand what’s going on in your feline’s mind midway this process.  

Wrong Temperature or Texture

Is your cat’s dry food too stale or wet food too cold or dry? Just like humans, cats have preferences when it comes to their food. They may prefer a certain texture or temperature and wouldn’t like to be fed otherwise.

If you’re still trying to figure out your cat’s preferences, start feeding warm food to your cat. Add warm broth or water and see if that’s the way your kitty prefers. If your cat is not too fond of wet food texture, the right kibble would do the trick. It is all about understanding your kitty’s preferences.  

Not Hungry

Cats love to sleep. They can sleep 12 to 16 hours in a day. This means that most indoor cats wouldn’t expend a lot of energy and that’s why they need very limited calories.

If your cat is refusing food or being picky, it could be simply because she isn’t hungry. They have low energy requirements and a few small meals are sufficient to keep them going. Do not panic if this is their regular feeding schedule. Consult a vet for any possible health problems if your cat has suddenly started to refuse food.

Health Problems and Allergies

Allergies are very common in cats, especially when it comes to some ingredients in their food. If they experience a reaction to a certain food, they’d probably refuse it the next time.

If you can’t figure out the actual reason for your cat’s new picky eating habits, it is best to consult a vet.

How to Feed a Fussy Eater

Here are some cool tips to help you feed your fussy kitty:

  • Offer more varieties of wet food – especially seafood flavors (the stinkier, the better)
  • Add canned anchovies or tuna water to their food
  • Add low-sodium chicken broth to their food – kibble or canned
  • Warm the food before serving
  • Use parmesan cheese as a food topper in moderate quantity to pique your cat’s appetite and interest
  • Use wet food toppers with shreds and chunks to add flavor and texture

FAQs

1. What do I do if my cat starts refusing her regular food?

Some cats have very distinct preferences when it comes to their food. They can be particular about the flavor of the food or texture or both. If your cat has become a fussy eater, consider replacing the supply or changing the texture. If your cat is turning their nose up to a certain food, it could be because it is stale or spoiled. If you have been feeding dry food exclusively, try introducing some wet food options and vice versa.

2. How do I figure out my cat’s favorite food?

Meat-based foods are not only more delicious but also more nutritious with higher protein content. Food with cooked chicken, beef, turkey, lean deli meats, and even seafood are some great options to introduce. If your cat is a picky eater, try offering a few different flavors and see which one he likes the most. That’s the best way to find out your cat’s favorite food.

3. Can I feed wet food to my cat everyday?

Yes, you can feed wet food to your cat on a daily basis. For feeding recommendations, it is best to seek assistance from a vet. As a general rule, an adult average-size cat should be fed 3-ounce of food per 3 to 3 ½ pounds of their body weight. This amount needs to be adjusted if you also feed them dry kibble.  

4. Do cats get bored eating the same thing everyday?

Just like humans, cats can get bored with the same food every day. To keep them excited about mealtimes, it is best to offer a variety of food. Another reason to do this is that it helps prevent certain health problems and allergies. If they continue with the same diet for an extended period, they often develop allergies to certain ingredients in that food.

5. Can I feed canned tuna to my cat?

Just like humans, cats can get bored with the same food every day. To keep them excited about mealtimes, it is best to offer a variety of food. Another reason to do this is that it helps prevent certain health problems and allergies. If they continue with the same diet option for an extended period, they often develop allergies to certain ingredients in that food.

Leave a Comment