The 13 Best Tasting Cat Foods for Picky Cats

By Nadine Oraby | 2020 Update

So you are looking for the best tasting cat food…

But you soon realize that the number of cat food brands out there are way too much. And how overwhelming it is to pick a good food product.

Well, in this guide I’ll review the best tasting cat foods for your furball.

But before that…You should know:

Why your kitty fur baby may have stopped eating??

Here are 8 common reasons (Video):


The Best Cat Foods for Picky Eaters

1) Taste of the Wild

Buy on Amazon

On top of our list is Taste of the Wild dry cat food. The best thing about this product is it contains a high percentage of protein since the main ingredient is meat. There is venison, salmon, chicken and trout meat. This combination is counted as a good source of amino acids that are required by your cat. Customers’ reviews of this product are 97% positive. It is 100% real meat and made in the USA.


2) Fromm FourStar Cat Food Gamebird

Another rich in meat protein product is Fromm FourStar dry cat food. This product not only offers duck or turkey meat but also includes pheasant and quail meat. These two meat types are so rare to find in any other product and that is what makes this product outstanding and distinguished.

A lot of cat owners admit that they have noticed that their cats’ skins have become shinier than ever and their furs have grown fuller which indicates that the cat’s health is improving!

This product, in particular, is Amazon’s choice. This product consists of the best nutrients that help in facilitating the cat’s digestion process. It is quality dry cat food and customers agree that their cats enjoy its taste so much.

Buy on Amazon


3) WELLNESS CORE Natural Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

Wellness Core dry cat food is made only for adult cats. This means that it is not recommended that you feed your kittens this product because it is not going to contain their required need of nutrients. One of the best things about this product is it consists of vitamins, minerals, fatty acids, probiotics, proteins, prebiotics, and carbohydrates.

This looks like a very balanced diet and also it is healthy because of the high percentage of real meat used in its production like turkey and chicken. This product is expensive but it is worth money because of its high quality and superb taste. It does not contain preservatives or flavor additives too.


4) Orijen Dry Cat Food

Orijen dry cat food is one of the richest products in real meat protein. It is also one of the highest quality dry cat food that is highly recommended by customers. It contains a good mixture of healthy ingredients that provide the cat with the needed nutrients for its growth like carbohydrates, protein, minerals, vitamins that improve cats’ health.

You can purchase that product in different sizes according to your budget. It is available on Amazon and could be shipped.


5) Castor & Pollux Organix

Castor & Pollux Organix could be purchased in different sizes as you wish. It is made in the USA and contains brown rice. It contains chicken meat which explains that it is rich in healthy protein for cats. It includes flaxseed and it is known that this nutrient helps in nourishing cats’ skin.

However, this product is not recommended for cats who gain weight easily because it contains a number of carbohydrates which might result in your cat’s obesity or illness.


6) Nulo Dry Cat Food

Nulo Dry Cat Food made in the USA and famous for its high percentage of natural ingredients that contain a sufficient amount of nutrients needed in a cat’s balanced diet. It is very highly recommended to purchase this product because veterinarians agree that it is a high-quality dry cat food that includes essential vitamins and nutrients.

What is so special about that product is that it has 0% grains; which means that the product’s first ingredient is real fresh meat high in healthy protein. Cats like it because of its small size that could be chewed easily; and also cat owners notice that their cats become energetic and active after they eat that dry food. It is also good that this product does not contain a high amount of carbohydrates.

All in all, people give 4.3 stars on Amazon. You can purchase it now online from Amazon and there is a coupon that offers you to save 40% when you first subscribe and save your order. It costs 22.99$ which quite affordable.


7) Wellness Divine Duos with Beef Pate & Diced Chicken Liver

Of course, there are hundreds of many other different choices and dry cat food brands; but it is also important to draw our attention to wet cat food too. Because wet cat food is very important and even healthier and more recommended than dry cat food.

This is because we previously mentioned that wet cat food contains moisture which is needed to exist in a cat’s diet since cats do not drink a lot of water during their day.

So the moisture gives some balance to their diet and helps in keeping them hydrated.

So let’s take a look at one of the best tasting and high-quality wet cat food which is: Wellness Wet Cat Food. Wellness is also available as a dry cat food as you have noticed on the list. Wellness brand is significant and famous because it provides both dry and wet cat food. This product is easy to open and to use.

It contains chicken liver which is diced and Beef Pâté. Cats like its taste so much and there is another thing that you need to know about this product. It is also recommended for cats that have kidney problems because this wet food has a very low percentage of phosphorous as a nutrient which is harmful to cats that suffer from kidney problems.

Customers give it 3 stars only because it is very expensive. It is currently unavailable on Amazon, but keep that product in mind in case you find it in any pet store…it is healthy for your feline friend.

8) Nature’s Logic

Nature’s Logic is an economical wet cat food product that comes in a case that contains 12 cans! People purchase this product more often because it saves them money and also lasts for a longer time. This wet food contains good moisture that nourished your cat and facilitates its digestive process.

This product contains carbohydrates which are found in the fruits and vegetables used ingredients. It is also interesting that there are not many calories; which helps in keeping your cat’s weight regular and good.

This product is rich in vitamins and minerals, it also consists of animal plasma and eggshell calcium. 95% of that product is made from real animal meat. It is available now in chicken, rabbit, sardine, salmon and turkey meat on Amazon.

9) Halo Spot’s Stew For Cats Wholesome Chicken Recipe

Halo Spot’s Stew For Cats Wholesome Chicken Recipe is a wet cat food which is highly recommended to purchase online from Amazon. It costs 19.03$ only which is a very attractive and affordable deal! You can order it in different sizes, not it is currently available in stock only.

This wet cat food is healthy for all cats’ ages. It is rich in chicken meat, liver, some veggies like carrots, zucchini and sweet potatoes. It tastes and smells so good! Warning alert!! This product contains an amount of garlic. Garlic is harmful for cats if they feed on it a lot. So make sure you do not feed your cat this product a lot, it is also recommended to give your cat a break from it every once in a while. Also, keep an eye on your cat’s reaction to see if it suffers from anything after it eats that wet food.

10) ZiwiPeak Canned Cat Cuisine New Zealand Beef Recipe

ZiwiPeak Canned Cat Cuisine New Zealand Beef Recipe this wet food brand is famous for its natural ingredients. Cow meat is used as the first ingredient. The best thing about that natural product is that the cows are never given hormones or antibiotics, so basically they are healthy cows that provide good meat. Cat owners notice that their cats enjoy this product’s taste so much. If you have a picky cat, this wet food is going to be its favourite!

Let’s take a look at some other well-known high-quality dry cat food like:

11) Blue Buffalo Wilderness

Blue Buffalo Wilderness, this is a dry cat food which is rich in chicken meat, grain-free, rich in vitamins, nutrients and natural minerals that improve your cat’s health. This product nourishes your cat’s health as well as its skin! Purchase now online for 34.98$ only! It is high-quality cat food that is rated 4.4 out 5! It is highly recommended by cat owners.

12) IAMS Protective Health

IAMS Protective Health is another very good dry cat food brand! It is rich in meat protein taken from chicken and turkey. It keeps your cat’s healthy weight and improves its health. It consists of nutrients that reduce hairballs. It nourishes the cat’s skin too. It does not contain a lot of fats. In other words, it is a balanced food product that is recommended by cat owners and veterinarians. People rate is 4.5 stars! This proves its success, besides its tastiness! It is very affordable, sold for 13.44$ only!

13) Meow Mix

Meow Mix is another quite affordable dry cat food which costs 15.98$ only! It comes in different sizes. This product is a 100% balanced nourishing cat food. It is the best example of a balanced cat’s diet. It consists of all the essential natural vitamins and minerals that a cat’s diet should consist of. It has a high percentage of protein that strengthens cats’ muscles.

Tips for Feeding Finicky Cats

Dr. Marty Becker offers tips for getting your finicky feline back to her healthy eating habits:

The Importance of Choosing The Right Cat Food

Beginner cat owners are usually not aware of the fact that a cat is not supposed to eat everything humans eat. They simply lack the basic knowledge that every pet owner, in general, should have; because animals require certain and different nutrients with specific percentages that must be found in their diet unlike us.

So when a beginner cat owner feeds their cat almost anything varying from rice, beans, potatoes, fish, bones and chicken, there is a bigger possibility that their cats get sick from one time to the other. The food which your cat eats could be responsible for its own lethargy, obesity, infections with diseases or stomach worms…etc.

Hence, choosing the right food for your cat is a top priority that should gain any pet owner’s attention. A good quality cat food is the one that consists of both grains and meat. Also, you need to look at the nutrients found in the food can to see if there is too much sugar in the food.

Too much sugar is not good for a cat’s health because it could lead to diabetes. So it is really important to check the nutrients on the food can. It is also highly recommended to buy expensive cat food because it consists of meat much more than grains. Not only that but also it does not have a lot of flavour additives and those artificial things that could have a harmful effect on your cat’s health in the future.

If you cannot afford to buy expensive cat food, just make sure you read carefully the nutrients found in each cat food can and stay away from products that lack the needed nutrients for a cat’s growth.

Things To Bear In Mind While Choosing A Good Quality Cat Food

Number one: you must definitely take the first look at the ingredients used in making that food. Since cats are carnivores (which means they eat meat), the first ingredient should be a type of meat. Meat is necessary to be found in a cat’s healthy diet.

Because cats need protein and they get their needed percentage of protein from meat as it contains a very high percentage of protein. Thus, if the first ingredient is grains, it is not a very welcoming sign that this cat food is the best one…it is okay to consist of grains but meat should be the first ingredient.

Warning alert!! Stay away from choosing a cat food that consists of preservatives and flavour additives because they are not good for your cat’s health by all means. Anything that contains BHT, BHA or sodium nitrate should be kept away from your cat’s reach even if your cat tried it once and seemed to enjoy it.

Keep your cat away from dangerous unhealthy food even if your cat thinks it tastes nice. It is better safe than sorry. Those artificial preservatives lead to problems in kidneys, blood pressure and causing illnesses. Therefore, natural ingredients are the best option!

One more important fact, cats do not drink water a lot during the day…so the best thing you can do is to provide them with wet food which has moisture in it. The moisture in the food will make your cat hydrated for as long as possible until it feels thirsty and drinks water.

Furthermore, cats have a sensitive digestive system and they gag easily if they ate something strange or unlikable to them…so it is always good to choose food that could be easily digested to avoid cat gags.

You don’t want to make your cat fat, right? This means that you need to cut off any carbohydrates in your cat’s diet. Carbohydrates make your cat gain weight easily and this could lead to obesity.

Types of Cat Food

Have you ever been confused about what kind of cat food should I buy for my cat? There are many brands and types of cat food out there in any pet store. Let us narrow the choices down a little bit.

There is dry cat food and wet cat food. Dry cat food does is not moisture and you’ll usually realize that it is roasted. Do not feed your cat a lot of dry food because it could lead to some problems in the long term because cats need some water in their diet. It is best to give your cat dry food as a treat only.

On the other hand, wet cat food consists of a high percentage of protein in the meat ingredient, plus it is cheaper than dry food.


You cat’s diet is important and necessary for its good health. This means that you need to be familiar with the right food products that you need to purchase for your cat. In a nutshell, you need to look at the ingredients used in the cat food, search for customer reviews because they would insight you a lot and according to the majority’s feedback, you will know if that cat food is recommended or not.

Also, it is always good to do a quick research about the cat food brands’ reputation. The brand’s reputation would definitely guide you about what to go ahead and buy and what to stay away from. Cat food products are so many and there are different choices, types, flavours and prices. Choose carefully what your cat likes and what is good for your feline friend’s stable health.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is dry food dangerous for cats?

Consuming large amounts of dry food could be really dangerous for your cat’s health. Dry food does not have enough moisture as that found in wet cat food. This dryness could lead to some problems in your cat’s urinary system like irritation or difficulty in urinating. This is because cats do not drink a lot of water during the day, so eating food that has moisture keeps them hydrated.

What can we do to add some moisture to cat dry food?

You can add some water to your cat’s dry food. Just a ¼ cup of filtered clean water would be just perfect for giving the dry food its needed moisture. Adding water to cat dry food helps prevent your cat’s dehydration.

What is some unhealthy food for cats?

Onions, vegetables, fruits because they contain a lot of sugar, potatoes, eggs, Chocolate, garlic, raw meat, raisins, deep-fried food, cooked tuna and raw liver. All those types of food are not good for a cat’s health.

Related Articles

Other Sources

So what pick do you consider to be the best cat food for your picky eater? Let me know in the comment section below!

Leave a Comment